By Carolyn Wyman
Originally published April 2011 at www.citypaper.net
It will soon be Easter, a time when even non-Italians swarm Philadelphia Italian bakeries for ricotta and ham pie, bunny cakes and Easter egg sweetbread.
But you have to be old or Sicilian to know about the Easter-time marzipan lambs.
These candy sculpture representations of Christ as Paschal lamb are an edible centerpiece of many an Easter meal. Sold in bakeries all over almond-loving Sicily, the lambs were also a fixture of Sicilian-American-owned Italian bakeries in the U.S. through the 1950s. But only a few Philly bakeries still make them.
The marzipan lamb is a 100-year-plus tradition at the 107-year-old Isgro Pasticceria (1009 Christian St., 215-923-3092, bestcannoli.com). Mary Sarno, 95, comes out of retirement every spring to make them from plaster molds hand-carved by her late father, bakery founder Mario Isgro, a Sicilian native.
“She can still fill a cannoli with a spoon,” Mary’s son, Isgro owner and baker Augustine “Gus” Sarno says admiringly. Mary no longer works Isgro’s busy counter (“I’m afraid someone will knock her over.”). But she can craft the lambs at her own pace in the old home kitchen off the bakery salesroom.
Gus actually makes the marzipan candy, a mixture of almond paste, corn syrup and sugar cooked at low-heat in copper kettles. Mary does what they both call the hardest part: Getting the candy in and out of the antique (and in one case, cracked) molds intact. Then she decorates them with royal icing flowers, pressed-sugar chicks, ribbon bows and jellybean eggs. It takes her up to a half-hour to create a single 4-to-6-inch lamb and six weeks to produce the 1,000 lambs Isgro’s sells in stages ($6.85 to $18.95 each) between Ash Wednesday and Easter. Said Gus last week, “If we put out everything out, we would have already run out. And then some of the families who’ve had these lambs on their Easter tables for generations would be disappointed.”
Unless, that is, they go to Varallo Bros. (1639 S. 10th St., 215-952-0367, varallobrothers.com), the other Philly bakery that still makes the lambs. At 43 years in the bakery business, Michael Varallo, 55, is a comparative novice at marzipan lamb-making. Varallo says he used to turn out hundreds for a local convent’s Easter feast but today only makes 150 undecorated ones. Even at $18, the lambs are money-losers. “I make them for the prestige,” he says in heavily Italian-accented English.
“There is no money in it,” agrees Gus Sarno. Nodding to his mother, he says, “She does it because she likes it and she loves me. If I had to pay someone? I don’t know what I’d do.”
(2019 update: Mary Sarno died in 2014. But both Isgro and Varallo Bros. bakeries still make marzipan lambs.)